Boyd Versus Black: Battle of the Illegal Immigration Ads

Anybody who doubts whether Tennessee voters, especially Republican Primary voters, are concerned about illegal immigration needs to watch a few of the early political ads that are starting to pound the airwaves. Candidates at every level, from state legislative races to Congressional races to the Governors race, are embracing a “tough on illegal immigration” stance intended to align with Tennessee voters. Support for President Donald Trump’s border wall gives prospective office holders a double bump, as they demonstrate their focus on illegal immigration and tie themselves to a political figure who still enjoys extremely high approval ratings among GOP primary voters.

The air war between Republican gubernatorial rivals Diane Black and Randy Boyd is the latest example of competing ads trying to “out illegal” their opponent.

In Boyd’s ad, he declares that “professional politicians have made a mess of our immigration system” – a not very thinly veiled shot at Congresswoman Diane Black. For those who might miss the point, the screen simultaneously shows a picture of the U.S. Capitol with the words “Washington Has Failed Us” in large capital letters. Boyd says “illegal is illegal” and promises to crack down on illegal immigration, support President Trump’s border wall, “no sanctuary cities”, wipe out violent gangs and “no drivers licenses or special benefits for illegal immigrants.”

While Boyd has been criticized in some circles for the ad being hypocritical based on a previous donation of $250,000 to Connexion, a pro-illegal immigration group, the ad has clearly been effective. Just a few days after the Boyd ad began airing, Black pulled a tv ad focused on her opposition to Planned Parenthood that had only aired for a few days and replaced it with her own illegal immigration ad.

The Black anti-illegal immigration ad highlights her opposition to a “catch and release” approach to illegals. While Diane Black is shown fishing on Old Hickory Lake she says catch and release is how “Washington handles illegal immigration.” The ad notes that “74% of all immigration arrests last year involved people with prior criminal convictions.” Black firmly declares that it is “time to get serious about illegal immigration” and that as Governor she will.

Although the Black ad doesn’t attempt to tie her to Trump directly, it does include a brief shot of the Trump Wall prototypes that provide a subtle reference. Her “tough on crime” approach is clearly intended to counter a recent Boyd commercial that detailed his law enforcement agenda.

Tennessee Star political editor Steve Gill points out that with both statewide and national polling show that illegal immigration is a top issue for Republican primary voters.  As a result, Tennessee airwaves will be flooded with ads devoted to that topic over the next few months.

“The issue of illegal immigration touches on several other points,” Gill says, “from economic concerns about jobs being taken by illegals, to the safety and security of our communities, to the risk of terror attacks that increase due to lack of border security, to outrage that taxpayer dollars are being used to benefit people who are illegally in this country. Illegal immigration has become an ‘umbrella issue’ that covers a variety of concerns.”

“No candidate will want to be perceived as being softer on the issue than their opponent, so we can expect the rhetoric to heat up dramatically in the next few weeks as campaigns at every level fight to be heard above the noise and confusion of crowd airwaves,” Gill notes.








Related posts

7 Thoughts to “Boyd Versus Black: Battle of the Illegal Immigration Ads”

  1. Kitty Lenoir

    Diane has been with the President since the beginning when it wasn’t a popular thing to do. Boyd is an unknown who could turn out to be a Haslam or a McCain. Not looking for more obstructionist, just looking to move the country and the President’s agenda forward.

    1. B J Zeagler

      Take a look at Diane’s voting record and the things she says that aren’t true, She is a true politician and will say whatever it takes to win. Things aren’t always as they seems. Match the ad put out on TV and listen to the things she has really done.

  2. Stuart I. Anderson

    Diane’s latest internal polls are very encouraging to those of us following the ANYBODY BUT BOYD strategy. Apparently Diane has a comfortable lead over Randy! with Harwell and Lee following behind. For conservatives, that’s OK, we’ll take it if only it’s true

  3. Wolf Woman

    La Raza Randy speaks with a forked tongue.
    He’s a snake in the grass in pursuit of power who pretends to be a conservative’s best friend.
    He is Haslam’s boy and will continue to fulfill the Haslam establishment platform.
    He is a buddy of big business who want illegals for cheap manpower. He wants to be a member of the oligarchy and has forgotten his middle class roots.

  4. They both are liars. We don’t need either. We need Bill Lee. The ads running against Black are correct and Boyd is nothing like President Donald J. Trump. Oh my goodness, I hope people do their homework. Ads mean nothing. Folks use your heads. Lee is a real business man and is against illegals, period. He is a real conservative, who will work with our President. Thank goodness for whoever put the truth out about Black. Diane Black ran a nasty dishonest campaign against Lou Ann Zelenik when she was elected to the congress. She worked hard in Murfreesboro for the Mosque. She is a RINO of the worse kind is part of the swamp. Google her record.

    1. Stuart I. Anderson

      Bill Lee is a “no-record” candidate – no record in political office, no record of political activism supporting conservative candidates, no record of financial support of perennially underfunded conservative candidates, no record of any conservative ideological advocacy before deciding to buy himself the governorship. NO RECORD!!!

      Conservatives should STOP voting for “no record” candidates, NOT Lee, NOT Rose, NOT Corlew, NOT Bulso, NOT. . .well, you get the idea. BTW, in the unlikely event it comes down to it, BETTER LEE THAN BOYD.

  5. 83ragtop50

    Having lived in the Houston, Texas area for many years prior to coming to Middle Tennessee in 2006, I can attest firsthand to the destructive impact of illegal aliens. While the rest of the country mostly ignored this horrible problem, Houston and virtually all of southern Texas was being buried in the filth, poverty and crime that comes with illegal immigration. It is way past the time to shut it down.