Dr. Carol M. Swain Commentary: White Officer’s Defense is Not Comparable to Nuremberg

by Dr. Carol M. Swain


How we talk about race does matter: Leaders have a responsibility to avoid fanning the flames of racism for political advantage, such as what’s happening in Nashville, Tennessee, where a familiar national story is repeating itself.

You know the storyline by now: A white police officer shoots and kills a black man who is running away from the officer—it’s a multiple tragedy on several fronts. The national media then goes overboard in reporting the story, as in this case with the likes of Newsweek and The New York Times among those amping up coverage of the Nashville shooting.

It’s a tragedy for the deceased, Daniel Hambrick, 25, and his family, which going forward is denied his presence and fellowship. It’s a tragedy for the Nashville community and for America as a whole, as well as for Andrew Delke, the 25-year-old police officer who fired the fatal shots.

It’s also a tragedy for the city and nation when Glenn Funk, the prosecutor in the case, decided to use incendiary and hyperbolic language at a preliminary hearing about whether criminal charges against the officer will advance.

Not hesitant to demonstrate his foolishness, Funk argued that Delke’s defense was similar to arguments “used at Nuremberg.”

During the Nuremberg trials, Nazi officers tried to justify their war crimes by claiming they were following orders. Chalk this up as yet another instance of the knee-jerk politically correct tactic of cluelessly bringing Nazis into the conversation.

Police Procedure

Delke encountered Hambrick while the white officer was in a black neighborhood investigating car thefts. Hambrick was one of three men who fled from the police. Delke’s defense is that he was following police procedure for dealing with armed suspects who refuse police orders. After seeing a gun in the suspect’s hands, Delke claims he gave verbal orders: “Drop the gun or I’ll shoot.”

Hambrick didn’t drop the gun, nor did he follow any other of Delke’s police orders. Video cameras show most but not all of the encounter between the two men. What is clear is that Hambrick was running away from Delke with a weapon in his hands. The cameras show Delke stop, aim, and shoot four bullets, striking Hambrick three times in the back.

Delke says he fired because he feared for his life and the safety of others. According to this theory, the armed suspect could turn in a second and fire at the officer or accidentally shoot bystanders. The officer claimed the suspect looked back at him briefly, but this wasn’t captured on videotape—there are a few seconds where the suspect is out of view. Delke’s defense about fearing for his life is one that most police officers give when they make the split-second decision to fire their weapon.

Following police training on how to respond to an armed suspect is hardly similar to the heinous crimes that Nazis perpetrated against the Jews. To say otherwise is utter nonsense. The issue seems to be the police training, which is undergoing review in many parts of the country.

From the beginning, the handling of the case has been problematic. The prosecutor engaged in judge shopping to get his criminal warrant. The warrant came after a night court magistrate (Evan Harris) had reviewed the evidence and concluded there wasn’t sufficient evidence to charge Delke. Dissatisfied with the outcome, Funk went to a different judge (Michael Mondelli) and got a criminal warrant that appeased protesters from Black Lives Matter and other social-justice groups who demanded a community oversight board for police actions.

The mayor had his fingerprints on the case. Nashville Mayor David Briley told The Tennessean he had spoken with Hambrick’s mother shortly after her son’s death and assured her that his life mattered. Hambrick’s mother asked for justice, and Briley said that Funk’s warrant was “a necessary step towards that end.”

In other words, the mayor welcomed the warrant the first judge refused to issue for lack of evidence. Delke became the first police officer in Nashville charged for a murder committed while on duty. His case now goes to a grand jury.

Racial Dynamics

Although Hambrick had a criminal record and had previously engaged in aggressive actions, those who believe the police officer acted out of racial animus argue that Delke had no way of knowing he was dealing with a person with a criminal record when he made the decision to fire his weapon. Delke, however, did know he was dealing with an armed black man.

Most likely, Delke was aware of demographic data showing racial disparities in crime rates and data on police shootings and ambushes. When he stopped, aimed, and fired, he was following police training and instincts in a high adrenaline situation.

A research study by professors Logan Strother and Charles Menifield, and research associate Geiguen Shin used data from 2014 to 2015 to provide an eye-opening account of police shootings and the racial dynamics involved. The results will be surprising for those with so much vested in racism as being a primary factor in police shootings.

The results indicate that “59.2 percent of people killed by white police officers were white; 28.2 percent of people killed by white officers were African American. Nonwhite officers were significantly more likely to kill nonwhite citizens, especially Latinos: 33.7 percent of the people killed by nonwhite officers were African American, and 32.6 percent were Latino …”

Blacks fitting the profile of Hambrick were more likely to be killed by minority law-enforcement officers. The researchers believe this is related to over-policing communities because of increased encounters between the police and crime suspects.

Racism wasn’t found to be a factor in the shootings, nor was there evidence of a significant pattern of white officers shooting unarmed blacks. More than 65 percent of the blacks killed in police encounters were armed. Less than 1 percent of unarmed suspects were killed in police encounters.

The prosecutor’s grandstanding and over-the-top rhetoric does more harm than good to the Nashville community and the larger national discussion about crime and law enforcement. His references to Nazis and Nuremberg follows an all-too-familiar leftist tactic of labeling conservatives as evil.

Funk’s willingness to judge-shop and spew incendiary language to advance a criminal case against Delke is shameful and doesn’t serve the interests of the community or the national conversation we should be having about law enforcement and crime in minority communities.

What Nashville and other American cities need are leaders who work with law enforcement and high-crime communities to educate the public and address legitimate concerns about how to police high-crime areas without stirring up racial animosity.

– – –

Dr. Carol M. Swain is a former tenured professor at Vanderbilt and Princeton universities. Her Be The People News blog and podcast empower individuals to think independently, understand their responsibility, and make a difference in the world. This article was previously published in The Epoch Times.










Related posts

6 Thoughts to “Dr. Carol M. Swain Commentary: White Officer’s Defense is Not Comparable to Nuremberg”

  1. […] Swain, C. (2019, Jan 13). Dr. Carol M. Swain Commentary: White Officer’s Defense is not comparable to Nuremberg. The Tennessee Star. Retrieved from: https://tennesseestar.com/2019/01/13/dr-carol-m-swain-commentary-white-officers-defense-is-not-compar… […]

  2. MarxFreeTV

    “…demographic data showing racial disparities in crime rates ” is being very polite. A careful review of TBI arrest statistics for 2015 showed that blacks were arrested for murder 9x as often as whites, and they were arrested for armed robbery 10x as often as whites. In fact, of the 20 odd categories of crimes, you have to get down to credit card and welfare fraud, stealing hubcaps, and picking up hookers before whites even get close to blacks when it comes to criminality.

    1. Kendra Tilley

      Could this be because blacks actually commit more violent crimes? These are facts always left out of the statistics to fan the fires of racism. I guess the officer should have just let the guy go because he was black??

  3. Myke Britt


  4. Proud Nashvillian

    Young men are killing each other at an alarming rate in Nashville. The police are NOT the problem.

    1. LEOs matter

      Agree… they are NOT the problem. Quite the contrary. They are the very ones trying their best to honor their commitment to protect and serve their communities. Please join me in prayer daily for our men and women in Blue. Their jobs are getting harder and harder. Thank you.