Judson Phillips Commentary: It Is Time To Break Up Tennessee’s Large Cities

It is time to break up Tennessee’s large cities.

Anyone with three functioning brain cells realizes the Tennessee Republican Party is not a conservative party and the Tennessee State legislature is a body that is of the lobbyists, by the lobbyists and for the lobbyists.

The Tennessee legislature will occasionally throw something out that is red meat for the Republican base, but for the most part they act like moderate Democrats. After all, without the Republicans in the state legislature, who would we have to expand government and raise taxes?

Conservatives need to start pressing the legislature to make some real small government reforms. One of the best reforms that could be made is to start breaking up Tennessee’s largest cities. This process has started with State Senator Bo Watson’s “De Annexation” bill, which passed the Senate this year and will be considered by the House next year.

Tennessee’s four largest cities have Democrat mayors. Memphis is well on its way to putting Detroit to shame as a murder capital and as the city most likely to end up in bankruptcy. Nashville, while a safer city, has had a series of mayors who put Music City on the way to fiscal insolvency.

Big cities become bastions of liberal government. While Tennessee is allegedly a deep red state, the four big city mayors keep growing and expanding government. They all drink the Kool-Aid and work for every liberal special interest group.

When Black Lives Matters protesters blocked Interstates in Memphis in 2016, the Memphis Mayor, Jim Strickland did nothing. People were stuck on the interstate for as much as four hours and an ambulance with a sick child could not get through.

Tennessee’s large cities are the bastions of failed liberalism in this state and it is time to put them down.


It is simple. The legislature can mandate that a city may grow to no more than a certain size. For the sake of discussion, let’s put that figure at 100,000 people. Just to put that in perspective the populations of the four largest Tennessee cities are, Nashville 685,000, Memphis, 656,000, Knoxville 185,000 and Chattanooga 174,000.

There are solid reasons to support breaking up Tennessee’s large cities. It is a simple, indisputable truth that smaller government works better. If you have a problem, you are much more likely to get answers and a response from a mayor or a city councilman in a city of 50,000 than you are in a city of 500,000.

When a city has large government, far too often, it is very easy for the mayor and other political leadership to start creating sinecures for their friends and allies. It is far too easy for liberal politicians to slide in wasteful and idiotic programs into the local budget with a large city that has a multi-billion dollar budget.

For fiscal year 2018 for example, Nashville’s budget is over $2.2 billion, which represents an almost 5.9% increase over the previous year. Some of that money is going to liberal causes like “affordable housing.”

Nashville spends 40% of its budget on schools that are generally regarded as failing.

Would a smaller city and therefore a smaller government help that? It certainly could not do any worse than Nashville or Memphis are currently doing.

Local governments have their purpose. Local governments exist to keep the streets paved and to provide fire and police services. But far too often, liberals use these big city governments as nothing more than slush funds for a liberal agenda at the local level.

It is time our allegedly conservative state republicans in the legislature do something about the big government liberalism at the local level. The best way to do that and to help the citizens of this state is to break up and limit the size of cities in this state.

# # #

Judson Phillips is a Tennessee attorney and founder of Tea Party Nation.

Related posts

8 Thoughts to “Judson Phillips Commentary: It Is Time To Break Up Tennessee’s Large Cities”

  1. E. J. Kane

    Amen and Amen.

    Small government = Small temptation to use that government club and corruption.
    Local and accountable; I think this is a absolutely great idea.
    Although we need to remember that this will create truly ultra-liberal urban centers where they will stop at nothing to demolish our Confederate history.
    Just a natural effect of surrendering our (formerly) great cities to a horde of minorities and interstate liberal parasites.

    Thank God they passed that law to protect these monuments and edifices to great men.

  2. Dwayne

    Cities. Concentrations of idiots who vote criminals into government. Cain built the 1st. Near all belong to lucifer.

  3. Ralph Pootawn

    Nashville’s tourism industry alone generates over twice the projected budget. What a blowhard.

    1. Bob

      Really? So Nashville’s city government will have an overwhelming cash surplus? I think not. Even if there was a huge surplus, Berry would find another ridiculous project to blow it on. Nashville is headed for such a deep financial hole that the sunshine will never reach the bottom. Go ahead. Live in your dream world if you want. You will be screaming for mercy as your taxes are raised sky high to cover the debt load. How do I know? I have lived through it in other “forward-looking”” large cities like Houston. and Atlanta.

  4. Bravo, what a great satirical piece! Have you ever considered writing for The Onion?

    1. No one cares what liberals think.

  5. Ruth Wilson

    I agree with Mr. Phillips. The Urban Growth 101 which had as it’s hallmark, FORCED Annexation, has been recinded by both Houses of the Tennessee legislature. The Municipalities can NOT FORCE their “growth” on the we, the people, any more. That, too, was legislation Sponsored in the Senate by Bo Watson. His De-Annexation Bill which passed this year, is just legislation. People who have been FORCED into annexations should be able to “DE-ANNEX”. Good for Bo Watson and Mike Carter and may God Almighty bless their work on ending this Wicked Urban Growth Legislation.
    Of course, the “lobby ” group opposing these good American pieces of legislation is the the Tennessee Municipal League, the Insurance company that provides the lowest “liability rates” to municipalities. This bunch is responsible for “pushing” the city growth ideas. Get rid of these “high powered Lobbyist” groups from the halls of the Tennessee Legislature.
    For God & Country