Vanderbilt University Medical Center (VUMC) denied allegations Wednesday that it introduced its “gender-affirming” clinic as a scheme to “make money for the hospital” and that employees with “religious beliefs” were warned they would suffer “consequences” for not participating in the transgender medical interventions.
Author and journalist Matt Walsh broke the story about Vanderbilt’s gender clinic that provides minors with body-mutilating surgeries and hormones that produce permanent, irreversible changes to children presented by parents as gender dysphoric.
Walsh told Fox News Channel’s Tucker Carlson Tuesday night:
We know for a fact…that [at] Vanderbilt they perform double mastectomies on minor girls…They give [children] irreversible hormone drugs that change their bodies permanently.
Asked by Carlson if he has spoken to anyone from Vanderbilt University Medical Center about his findings, Walsh said he reached out to the hospital for a statement when he first published his report.
“At first, they didn’t want to give a statement and they, and they actually just took down … they just deleted … their entire transgender clinic website, they wiped it from existence,” Walsh added, noting Vanderbilt released a statement “claiming there’s misinformation, and so on.”
.@MattWalshBlog talks to @TuckerCarlson about Vanderbilt's transgender clinic: "We know for a fact…that [at] Vanderbilt they perform double mastectomies on minor girls…They give [children] irreversible hormone drugs that change their bodies permanently." pic.twitter.com/rJ6usEHfB6
— Daily Wire (@realDailyWire) September 22, 2022
Walsh continued Vanderbilt had not actually denied what his report of their alleged video presentations said:
They don’t actually factually dispute anything in my report because they can’t, because everything that I said wasn’t me saying it, I was just providing video evidence, much of which you played there. Well, we know for a fact, this is an absolute fact that, that Vanderbilt, they performed double mastectomies on minor girls, on children. They chemically castrate children, and they give them irreversible hormone drugs that change their bodies permanently. They’re doing all of that to kids.
According to a partial statement reported Tuesday by the Tennessean, Vanderbilt said regarding Walsh’s report:
VUMC began its Transgender Health Clinic because transgender individuals are a high-risk population for mental and physical health issues and have been consistently underserved by the U.S. health system.
We have been and will continue to be committed to providing family-centered care to all adolescents in compliance with state law and in line with professional practice standards and guidance established by medical specialty societies.
The Tennessean reported Vanderbilt also said employees of the hospital are permitted to abstain from participating in medical care they find “morally objectionable,” including those interventions related to transgender issues, and that parental consent is required to treat a minor “for issues related to transgender care.”
Fox News Digital reported VUMC denied any wrongdoing or that its gender clinic performs unethical transgender surgeries on minors, defending its treatments as requiring “parental consent.”
“VUMC requires parental consent to treat a minor patient who is to be seen for issues related to transgender care and never refuses parental involvement in the care of transgender youth who are under age 18,” the statement reportedly read.
A number of lawmakers, including Governor Bill Lee (R-TN) and U.S. Senator Marsha Blackburn (R-TN), and faith leaders condemned Vanderbilt, calling for both investigations into its “gender-affirming” clinic and for legislation outlawing any transgender medical interventions for minors.
Lee told The Tennessean Vanderbilt’s “pediatric transgender clinic” raised “serious moral, ethical and legal concerns,” and added that an investigation into the clinic would be necessary.
Casey Sellers, the governor’s communications director, said Lee’s office had already been in contact with state Attorney General Jonathan Skrmetti.
“We are aware of allegations of illegal conduct at the Clinic for Transgender Health at Vanderbilt University Medical Center,” Skrmetti’s office said in a statement. “General Skrmetti will use the full scope of his authority to ensure compliance with Tennessee law.”
Tennessee will become the first state in the country to make surgical and medical “gender transitions” for children illegal. We will pave the way. This is just the beginning.
— Matt Walsh (@MattWalshBlog) September 22, 2022
Tennessee Senate Majority Leader Jack Johnson (R), who represents Williamson County, said he and state Representative William Lamberth (R-Portland) are “appalled” by what Walsh “uncovered at VUMC.”
“We’re going to do everything we can to stop it,” Johnson added.
.@WilliamLamberth and I are appalled by what @MattWalshBlog uncovered at VUMC. We're going to do everything we can to stop it.
Watch @TuckerCarlson → pic.twitter.com/U03eCTy64m— Jack Johnson (@SenJohnson) September 22, 2022
Great to run into @MattWalshBlog @theMRC tonight, and I appreciate his work in exposing what the left is doing to our children.
Stay tuned for more tomorrow about how puberty blockers are being used on children. @VUMChealth @US_FDA pic.twitter.com/PtLGiT6f6i
— Sen. Marsha Blackburn (@MarshaBlackburn) September 22, 2022
Catholic League President Bill Donohue, PhD also responded to the allegations against Vanderbilt in his role as the leader of the nation’s largest Catholic civil rights organization.
In one of the videos Walsh published, Vanderbilt’s Ellen Wright Clayton, J.D., M.D., a professor of pediatrics, law, and health policy, and the co-founder of Vanderbilt University School of Medicine’s Center for Biomedical Ethics and Society, warned staff that “conscientious objectors” are “problematic,” and that personnel who refuse to be involved in transgender surgeries due to their “religious beliefs” will face “consequences.”
Donohue sent a letter to Dr. Daniel Diermeier, chancellor at Vanderbilt, to assert his opinions regarding the comments Clayton is heard making in the video.
In his letter, the Catholic leader declared as “excellent” the following statement released by Vanderbilt:
Our policies allow employees to decline to participate in care they find morally objectionable, and do not permit discrimination against employees who choose to do so. This includes employees whose personal or religious beliefs do not support gender-affirming care for transgender persons.
“My only concern is why Dr. Clayton would think that what she allegedly said could ever be seen as legal, never mind ethical,” Donohue wrote to Diermeier. “One would think that someone in her role as a health law expert would know better. I trust she has been told that conscience rights are integral to religious liberty and must be protected.”
Walsh told Carlson the so-called “gender-affirming care” provided to children is “happening all across the country, in every single state, in many hospitals and in many other medical clinics, all of those things are happening”:
And one of the reasons why it’s allowed to keep happening is because people don’t know about it because they’re not talking about it. And I think for a lot of average Americans, people just walking down the street, it’s sort of unthinkable, they can’t imagine that this sort of thing is actually happening.
“Which is why we have to start by raising awareness about it, and we have to do that no matter … the game the Left plays by saying if you, if you so much as mention what they’re doing,” Walsh added. “Yes, incitement and terrorism, which is, which is absurd. But we can’t we can’t bend to that tactic. We have to keep shining a light on this.”
Left-wing media outlet The Daily Beast’s headline about the story read, “Vanderbilt Medical Clinic Shuts Down Its Website After Transphobic Attack.”
The Star News Network/Tennessee Star reached out for comment to VUMC and is awaiting a response.
– – –
Susan Berry, PhD, is national education editor at The Star News Network. Email tips to [email protected].
Photo “Vanderbilt University Medical Center” by Vanderbilt University Medical Center.
I worked there and can tell you from personal experience, Vanderbilt Risk Management is working overtime to cover the hospitals tracks. Hard drives are being erased, documents are being destroyed and nurses and doctors careers are being threatened if they speak out. After Obama Care was implemented, the culture of “patient first” became a thing of the past. Profit became the overriding bottom line. The older, ethical minded, doctors and nurses were run off because they disagreed with upper level management’s profit motives. To get rid of you they made your life miserable. They started nit-picking everything you did in the name of proficiency. You found yourself going from “model employee” to “problem employee” in a matter of weeks. The constant threats of termination and being “written up” forced many of the more experienced medical staff, those not on board with the new think, to seek employment elsewhere. It went from being a place you enjoyed working at to a place you dreaded going to work. The newer nurse and doctor graduates are indoctrinated from the first day to march lock step with the new profit model. Vandy claims to be an educational and non-profit institution of healing. It’s no longer. It’s a profit hungry monster. Want good care? Try St. Thomas or Tri-Star (Cenntiniel).
“My only concern is why Dr. Clayton would think that what she allegedly said could ever be seen as legal, never mind ethical,” Donohue wrote to Diermeier.
I’m not sure why Diermeier used the word “allegedly” when I saw the video and heard Dr. Clayton say that employees couldn’t use religious exemption and those who didn’t fall in line with the procedures would suffer consequences . . . if they didn’t agree then they could go work somewhere else. Dr. Clayton is also Vanderbilt Law school professor, for the Lord’s sake. It would be interesting to know what she’s teaching.
VU Medical Center is lying to cover up what they see as a huge PR blooper. But they can’t cover it up. Lying with video and website screen shots out in the public is not good damage control. Their kids’ “gender” transition clinic, which seemed like such a great idea to the bean counters and progressive administration, is now national news. Shame on you Vanderbilt, shame on you!
“Pediatric” and “Transgender” do not belong together as descriptors. The fact that they are indeed used together to describe a Vanderbilt clinic, or any other clinic, says something very wrong has infiltrated the world of medical practice – psychiatric practice too for that matter. And Vanderbilt is now denying statements made by their own employees recorded on video?? Wow.