Esperanza Yanez, an attorney employed by the Nashville Public Defender’s Office, published at least four posts to social media claiming her lack of “empathy” for the assassination of Charlie Kirk was justified by claiming the Turning Point USA founder was a “fascist organizer.”
Yanez first publicly commented on Kirk’s assassination on Wednesday afternoon, only hours after he was killed, when she claimed that Kirk, “said he loved the genocide occurring in Palestine and wanted to see more of it,” before adding an emoji depicting a woman shrugging.
Hours later, Yanez (pictured above) wrote in another post, “demanding empathy for a hateful person like this is insane,” and derided others for praying for the victims of other tragedies, including, “black and brown people killed by police brutality, and CIVILIANS taken out by isnotreal’s military force.”
The portmanteau, “isnotreal,” was defined by a scholarly journal in 2024 as “coded wordplay,” used with the goal of “presenting Israel as a fictional state and implicitly denying Israel’s right to exist.”
One day later, Yanez posted a lengthy text about Kirk to her social media.
“He wasn’t just a ‘conservative we disagreed with,'” Yanez shared. “He was a fascist organizer who built his career spreading racism, misogyny, homophobia, transphobia, Islamophobia, xenophobia, and anti-immigrant hate, actively harming marginalized communities every single day.”
The post stated, “Empathy is not owed to oppressors. Mourning is not mandatory. Pretending that ‘civility’ in the face of fascism makes you morally superior is nothing but cowardice.”
A fourth image posted by Yanez claimed that those against “political violence” must also declare their opposition to a number of other issues, including, “ongoing attacks on trans rights,” and “the mass genocide, starvation, and abuse of Palestinians, Congolese, Sudanese [and] more.”
She captioned the post, “otherwise you’re just a hypocrite.”
Yanez’s biography on the Nashville Public Defenders Office website states that she is a 2021 graduate of the University of Tennessee Winston College of Law. A former law school classmate of Yanez told The Tennessee Star that while he recalled similar politically charged statements from Yanez as a law student, he was surprised to see such rhetoric from a public defender.
“Imagine if her posts got out there, and were seen by members of public, and she were identified as a public defender,” said the classmate. “Particularly for people on the [political] right, imagine how it would shake their confidence in this system, where they’re supposed to be getting fair representation no matter what.”
The classmate told The Star, “These posts imply political animus and hatred for people who disagree with her. Would I be confident that person is going to give me their best representation, or are they going say, I don’t care about what happens?”
According to the Tennessee Board of Professional Responsibility (TBPR), Yanez has been licensed to practice law in Tennessee since 2022.
Yanez did not respond to a press inquiry from The Star prior to press time.
The Nashville Public Defenders Office, which states that its mission is to “defend the life, liberty, honor and constitutional rights of the individuals, of all ages, whose cases have been entrusted to us,” similarly did not respond to an inquiry from The Star which sought to confirm Yanez’s statements and ascertain whether the office has a social media policy for its attorneys.
The Star additionally contacted the TBPR to ascertain if Yanez’s statements generated ethical concerns, but the board said it could not comment on individuals except through formal public disclosures of disciplinary actions.
Notably, the Tennessee Rules of Professional Conduct prohibit attorneys from, “conduct involving dishonesty, fraud, deceit, or misrepresentation,” or “that is prejudicial to the administration of justice.”
Kirk was killed last Wednesday while holding an event at Utah Valley University. His alleged assassin was identified as Tyler Robinson, a 22-year-old who reportedly lived with a transgender romantic partner. Authorities recovered a rifle and ammunition engraved with antifascist and sexually suggestive statements near where Kirk was shot.
– – –
Tom Pappert is the lead reporter for The Tennessee Star, and also reports for The Pennsylvania Daily Star and The Arizona Sun Times. Follow Tom on X/Twitter. Email tips to [email protected].
Photo “Esperanza Yanez” by Nashville’s Public Defender’s Office.

////i’m sure she’s a fav of Nashvilles pencil necked mayor.”””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””””
Action must be taken. Words have consequences.
Working in government and making false accusations About CK. She must be a terrible lawyer if her reasoning and research is so bad. This Assassination tolerant individual should be fired.
It sounds like this “public defender” Yanez is ready to present an Amicus Brief in support of Tyler Robinson for his murder trial!
I wonder if this Esperanza comprehends that she is living and working on occupied land stolen from Native-Americans in a relentless genocidal war of ethnic cleansing. Apparently she has no empathy for that either!
Remove immediate
She needs to be summarily fired.
This is what happens when you put non-Americans is positions of power. They can go back home and play with their goats.
she will probably get promoted there
People like her with an obvious bias have no business in any form of law enforcement. She should not only be fired she should have her license to practice law revoked. Not because of WHAT she said but because it indicates she has an agenda and serving the law fairly doesn’t appear to be part of that agenda. Every statement she made about Charlie Kirk is evidence that she has never really listened to anything Charlie has ever said. I want her to post the very speech Charlie Kirk gave in which he said that….. “he loved the genocide occurring in Palestine and wanted to see more of it,” He cherished the word of the Bible and like God Charlie loved the sinner but did not support the sin. If anyone is a racist it is this woman. It is obvious she has a real problem and should not be serving in our state at any capacity.
From the first link in the article: she is a member of “Nashville Defenders” an organization that has the socialist (Marxist) graphic as its logo, the upraised clenched fist. Very telling!
How can this woman be objective and serve the general public? Her socialist totalitarian ideology of “the ends justify the means” will always come first before U.S. law. She’s revealed her ignorance of American law, the history of Islam and Israel and her nasty hateful streak on a social media platform. Now it’s up to us to let everybody know what she represents.
Thanks for this article, Tom. Please keep an eye on her
She needs to be fired – yesterday!
This person also should not be there. She will be as many in Nashville Government feel the same way she does. Unless the heat is really turned up on them, nothing will change